Seems like it. I got mine and cant get it to show either.
Yeah the resetting is whats screwing you over. I got mine after maybe 5 tries. But to add to the Bugs see the one above. Also please move the dudes talking to monster say so we can filter it out. Right now its on the normal say :/
Edit: An other bug with the Pies. If you take the quest with more than 10 "Guts" (named Insides in your inventory) it wont register them. You have to create a new one to get the quest to work. BUT if you have more than 10 Guts it will use up all of them. First try took 21 of them and the 2nd try took 11 :/