New Player Experience - Some Feedback
Posted: Sun Feb 01, 2026 8:19 pm
Hey guys,
I'm a seasoned mmorpg player, played Warhammer Online a small amount when it released back then and after years and years of roaming around through different mmorpgs I made my way into Return of Reckoning. First of all I have massive respect for the work that is put into this to keep this game alive. The game deserves it as it is something really special. So I want to leave some feedback how the game feels to me as a newbie. In my job I am always grateful for outside perspectives so maybe you like that too.
So the beginning of the game is insanely fun. Getting your feet wet in a little tutorial and then jumping right into tier 1 rvr is super fun. It's easy to get into. It's welcoming. The gear progression is beautiful and the rvr system feels like the sweet spot between instanced pvp like it is in most theme park mmorpgs and pvp only gank fests like Albion or Ashes (RIP). All rounded up with the great fantasy of Warhammer which still holds up in it's unique art style that is put into this game.
But then: Level 16. You now are somehow being pushed into the role of an outlaw. It feels like you are always in the wrong place trying to play rvr. As for tier 2,3 and 4 are merged together you have to play with the big boys now. I'm cool with that. But it is really hard to find a group that is actually welcoming. Most of the groups have +30 or +40 restrictions or are like "[random race] only". So you don't get in in the first place. When you finally make it into a group it always feels like being the weakest link despite bolstering. Not rarely wb members starting to moan about the amount of low levels when something goes wrong. And I understand high level players preferring to play with other high level players because it is more fun and it is more reliable. So the game system leads to this point of friction which is not ideal.
I would highly appreciate if tier 4 would be separated from the other tiers so you don't fall into a deep hole after reaching level 16. It doesn't feel great to be just merely tolerated as a low level character. It's a bit excluding. So I really think the society of RoR could be more lively if it was more welcoming on a structural level. Not meaning that there aren't a lot of welcoming players.
I know that you can't make every tier exclusive because population spikes around new players and high level players with not a lot of people in between. In my opinion it could be a good idea to combine tier 1,2 and 3 instead of 2,3 and 4.
Anyway, a good idea on how to close the gap between tier 1 and 4 could be very beneficial to the game I think.
I'm a seasoned mmorpg player, played Warhammer Online a small amount when it released back then and after years and years of roaming around through different mmorpgs I made my way into Return of Reckoning. First of all I have massive respect for the work that is put into this to keep this game alive. The game deserves it as it is something really special. So I want to leave some feedback how the game feels to me as a newbie. In my job I am always grateful for outside perspectives so maybe you like that too.
So the beginning of the game is insanely fun. Getting your feet wet in a little tutorial and then jumping right into tier 1 rvr is super fun. It's easy to get into. It's welcoming. The gear progression is beautiful and the rvr system feels like the sweet spot between instanced pvp like it is in most theme park mmorpgs and pvp only gank fests like Albion or Ashes (RIP). All rounded up with the great fantasy of Warhammer which still holds up in it's unique art style that is put into this game.
But then: Level 16. You now are somehow being pushed into the role of an outlaw. It feels like you are always in the wrong place trying to play rvr. As for tier 2,3 and 4 are merged together you have to play with the big boys now. I'm cool with that. But it is really hard to find a group that is actually welcoming. Most of the groups have +30 or +40 restrictions or are like "[random race] only". So you don't get in in the first place. When you finally make it into a group it always feels like being the weakest link despite bolstering. Not rarely wb members starting to moan about the amount of low levels when something goes wrong. And I understand high level players preferring to play with other high level players because it is more fun and it is more reliable. So the game system leads to this point of friction which is not ideal.
I would highly appreciate if tier 4 would be separated from the other tiers so you don't fall into a deep hole after reaching level 16. It doesn't feel great to be just merely tolerated as a low level character. It's a bit excluding. So I really think the society of RoR could be more lively if it was more welcoming on a structural level. Not meaning that there aren't a lot of welcoming players.
I know that you can't make every tier exclusive because population spikes around new players and high level players with not a lot of people in between. In my opinion it could be a good idea to combine tier 1,2 and 3 instead of 2,3 and 4.
Anyway, a good idea on how to close the gap between tier 1 and 4 could be very beneficial to the game I think.