Return of Reckoning

In my opinion, go with SH. You can melee in WB, City, SC. Ranged in SC, small-scale, etc. You're more survivable, and you're easier to gear because Squig Armor (melee "stance") converts all your ranged dps stats on items to melee stats. Some of the most fun I've had in the game is mSH boun...

No SM IB and BG all deal more dmg. This is correct, but that shouldn't discourage you from playing what you like. To my knowledge, the only tank not really capable of dealing good damage is KotBS. So out of the other remaining tanks, take your pick of playstyle, aesthetic, and mechanics/specific bu...