Return of Reckoning

I echo Penril and Volgograd's thoughts, and believe that we must compare it against other tanks if we are to deduce whether or not it is overperforming: So I guess my thought (I posted in more wall-o-text format) is why not just MATCH these two abilities to the SM/BO knowing that the abilities do n...

Well my opinion: EDIT. Sorry Penril: Keep BO/SM/BG/IB (they also have a channel) out of the discussion. Are these 2 skills underperforming for what they cost? Yes/No? Currently both moves are so bad, nobody uses them. One factor is loss of AA during the attacks. Second is they serve no real purpose ...

I feel like I need to say this again; we are not looking forward to nerfing these classes. How would it work? Well, you start at 0, and up to 70 you will be doing slightly more damage than you currently do. At 71, you do more damage/have more chance to crit than you currently do at 100. But if you ...

Well, considering most SCs are either PUG groups, or uncoordinated groups sure it will work.

If you ever come across a real group, like a 2-2-2 with real DPS, real tanks, and real healers you will get rolled.

But I would wager you can probably win 8 out of 10 SCs with almost ANY premade group.

Well i got a sorcerer 40 and dropped it because lack any survival cd vs melee and especially when i was 100 at charge i was milling myself. Your point is correct i assume. The mechanic is simple:more energy means more dmg output. To rework that stuff you musto touch the nerve of the class meaning a...

then what about setting treshold for skills? for example the most potent ones requires an amount of charge to be casted, but the more you accumulate the more you get damage by self debuff crit (pretty much like melee dps like choppa and slayers who must learn to manage enrage no?) Main difference i...

why instead of penalize wounds or take self damage you dont impose a simple chance to get crit by 1%...then 2% so on staking to max of 15%? Easy. Because this doesn't constitute any management or skill or anything penril wanted to accomplish. This would mean a BW or Sorc gets to 100. Stays in 100, ...

Why make punishing mechanic? Just make them choose to drop mechanic point cos of different benefits. For example I would make something like that: 0-25 combustion = 0% dmg; 50% crit 26-50 combustion = 25%; 40% crit 51-75 combustion = 50% dmg; 30 crit 76-100 combustion = 80% dmg; 0 crit Ps numbers a...

I would wholly support this. I only have played IB in tier 1/2 PVP and have played with both of these and it IS annoying, very restrictive, and a large consumer of Grudges which makes it much more limiting to do your primary job of a TANK. I also main a BG and FULLY understand the frustration of the...

For years I have been saying 2H needs to be reworked. Frankly... This is BETTER than blockstrike through but am I allowed to voice my opinion that I think this should be swapped with DW? DW should have dodge/disrupt 2H should have Parry. Why? many reasons, it is easier to "dodge" with DW -...