Very interesting, I also did the same and felt kotbs was "embarrassingly stronger".th3gatekeeper wrote:chosen>kotbs
20% crit is such a massive bonus it can be the "only thing" a knight has over a chosen and still be much stronger.
What chosen has is crip strikes and destined for victory. And even then cripp strikes has an activator problem because chosen need shields in orvr and lose out on rending blade as a result. The other stuff you mentioned are not really important. Damage type is negligible because your job isnt damage anyways. Tooth and Shining blade give non physical damage types so both classes benefit equally there. Suppression vs Shield rush is a tie because guard dmg isnt the only type of dmg you take and you need that block % to limit area/direct hits.
What you are correct on is that knights shouldnt ever go 2h. Chosen probably not either except in SC maybe.
edit: forgot you need block to proc destined for victory, so there is even less reason to go 2h on chosen. destined for victory is very very good, allowing rapid use of chosen's strong morales. id say its the best thing chosen has.
Wtf is this "guard bot" nonsense? You have still have to do your job as a tank... actively cc-ing and doing other tank things. If you think your job is the put on auras and guard on a dps and try to mash people down with ravage or knight abilties you are hopeless beyond salvation.
If you want to be the star of the show with l33t dmg why did you pick a support archetype and not a damage class?