Return of Reckoning

The only feasible option for a 2h tank is Chosen. The damage increase is negligible, you go 2h because of the combination of Crippling Strikes, 15% crit tactic, undefendable AoE attack and 25% parry increase. This allows you to have 25% damage reduction on all enemies at all times with a decent ...

You need a Chosen in your group at the moment. Resistance aura is essential fighting BW's because every good tank will remove Shaman buff during fight.

1. Complaining about group play in a MMO is a bit weird.
2. Complaining about the most effective way to play classes or how to setup a group in a PvP game is a bit weird.
3. Complaining about better players in a PVP game is a bit weird.

I recommend to play a single player game. Instant action, you ...