Shadowgurke wrote:
1) The fact that many people, including OP, have misconceptions about Guard is a bad ground to base a debate on.
Guard is horribly strong but at the same time half the reason why tanks even exist in the current form. Healing is also horribly strong, no?
2) I want to state this again, Guard damage is not negligible for tanks at this point in time. If for some reason in T4 tanks can parry/block 90% of all attacks we can discuss this again
To start with 2) It is not exactly 90% but very close to that in terms of guard defence yes. Not for 'some' reason, but for the fact that they simply can stack their defense so ridiculously high through morales, tactics and base skills + the RR skills (which got buffed compared to AOR actually)[ RR defense skills are not mitigated by int/str/Balli anymore, while they were back on live]
1) That they were wrong was already stated multiple times, but instead of me or someone else starting a new topic i rather try to 'educate' them here or point out the misconceptions and errors that were made. I am by no means always right with my opinions either, but alone from the numbers that will be achieved later on in the game i can guarantee you that, guarded damage is laughable at best later on if it stays like it is. Therefore i am just saying in advance that the topic "Guard" may be looked at by now already.
------
Tesq wrote:
it happen when there are no evidence appart that guard is op with nor a video/screen, proved wb vs wb fight in which none was able to kill none due to guard.
This thread opened with no base proves that guard is op, i didn't see not even 1, and not even 1 logic reason why it is compared to other pvp/rvr games after war which in fact all suck due to not have guard appart swotor which still have guard but is not revolved around such big scale fight as war is and so there guard is a lot less powerfull than here.
Because war is revolved aroud big scale fight right? or need this to also be check?
wb vs wb ... Rly? Having 4-8 DDs potentially focusing on one target is no foundation of any discussion either.
There is no need for any video proof of guard being op, because the numbers (even now a chosen has 20% block and about 70% parry) alone should tell you that it is.