WH - Trial by Pain

[peterthepan3]

I wouldn't even bother with mass analysis, because it doesn't matter what random players use. Look at what the best groups are using and you'll likely see 0 Trial by Pains.

That's for certain, if in any case an analysis is needed - how one can determine the best groups?

Aka those that kill 99% of their opponents quickly and regularly, and utilise the best skills per class to achieve this success. If you're using trial by pain as a witch hunter, then you need to rethink your life.

[Tklees]

I wouldn't even bother with mass analysis, because it doesn't matter what random players use. Look at what the best groups are using and you'll likely see 0 Trial by Pains.

That's for certain, if in any case an analysis is needed - how one can determine the best groups?

Those who excel at their classes in multiple settings. RvR, SCs, and 1v1. As to WH I sincerely think a buff to dragon Gun and a tweak to the aoe razor strike tatic would make all of their specs viable. My suggestion to those ends would be a damage increase to dragon Gun of about 15-20% and an increase of the targets aoe razor could hit from 3 to 4.

[Tklees]

Thinking about this some more to make it hotbar worthy.

It could be changed to proc bullets according to how many accusations you have with a minimum of 2. 5 procs for 5 accusations would be tasty.

Remove AP cost and have it return AP over the course of the channel with a base of say 20 per accusation. So a 1 accusation TbP would return 20 AP over 3 seconds, 5 accusation TbP would return 100 AP over 3 seconds and so on.

I think a simple decrease in the length of the channel, compressing the damage, and 1 extra bullet proc would make it bar worthy

[Jaycub]

Trial by pain needs some kind of utility attached to it otherwise it will just inferior to absolution unless you make it OP. It needs to have some kind of niche use that will make it usable in certain situations, or in certain builds.

An example I can come up with on the spot, maybe on each class every hit has a chance to remove a positive effect from the target, or turn it into a ranged snare like withering heat, or maybe while channeling you are invulnerable to damage from that target, etc...

[Tklees]

Trial by pain needs some kind of utility attached to it otherwise it will just inferior to absolution unless you make it OP. It needs to have some kind of niche use that will make it usable in certain situations, or in certain builds.

An example I can come up with on the spot, maybe on each class every hit has a chance to remove a positive effect from the target, or turn it into a ranged snare like withering heat, or maybe while channeling you are invulnerable to damage from that target, etc...

Dont bundle it all together, bullet point it :p

I like the channeled snare concept, especially since the class lacks access to a real snare and the blessed bullets of confession were originally a snare and dot component and it has utility both in catching and escaping. The invulnerable one I could see having some massive issues though

Only issue here is if WHs get a melee snare, WEs need it mirrored