Broadhead Arrow Suggestion.

[Caduceus]

Channeled AoE abilities were limited to the strongest instance only, because stacking them would break the game.

Stacking BHA leads to the exact same situation, and predictably it is breaking the game.

There is no mystery here.

[Justina]

Decorate it as you like but a dot ticking 1.6k is not something normal. Having 4 of them on you simply serves as an oil effect. There is a design mistake on this ability. The dmg of the tick multiplies with each stack. So while 2x BHA crits for 800 and 3x for 1.6k. This craziness must be fixed.

Don't spread false information here. BHA is not ticking for 1.6k.

3x BHA usually ticks around 200-600. In some rare cases you might get a 1k tick but that's on very squishy targets with damage boost and armor debuff. On the other hand there are also tanks and guarded WEs or maras where it ticks for pretty much nothing. One hot can counter it.

Post screenshots. That 1.6k is for sure a lie or a one in a million tick.

[Onigokko0101]

Decorate it as you like but a dot ticking 1.6k is not something normal. Having 4 of them on you simply serves as an oil effect. There is a design mistake on this ability. The dmg of the tick multiplies with each stack. So while 2x BHA crits for 800 and 3x for 1.6k. This craziness must be fixed.

Don't spread false information here. BHA is not ticking for 1.6k.

3x BHA usually ticks around 200-600. In some rare cases you might get a 1k tick but that's on very squishy targets with damage boost and armor debuff. On the other hand there are also tanks and guarded WEs or maras where it ticks for pretty much nothing. One hot can counter it.

Post screenshots. That 1.6k is for sure a lie or a one in a million tick.

WTF is this. I get more then 200-600 as a full Merc fresh 40 SW.
A full BiS SW is going to be getting ~900 non-crit on non-tanks with 3x

[Winry]

Decorate it as you like but a dot ticking 1.6k is not something normal. Having 4 of them on you simply serves as an oil effect. There is a design mistake on this ability. The dmg of the tick multiplies with each stack. So while 2x BHA crits for 800 and 3x for 1.6k. This craziness must be fixed.

Don't spread false information here. BHA is not ticking for 1.6k.

3x BHA usually ticks around 200-600. In some rare cases you might get a 1k tick but that's on very squishy targets with damage boost and armor debuff. On the other hand there are also tanks and guarded WEs or maras where it ticks for pretty much nothing. One hot can counter it.

Post screenshots. That 1.6k is for sure a lie or a one in a million tick.

WTF is this. I get more then 200-600 as a full Merc fresh 40 SW.
A full BiS SW is going to be getting ~900 non-crit on non-tanks with 3x

How about you show us some proof instead of throwing numbers around.

[Littleone]

Decorate it as you like but a dot ticking 1.6k is not something normal. Having 4 of them on you simply serves as an oil effect. There is a design mistake on this ability. The dmg of the tick multiplies with each stack. So while 2x BHA crits for 800 and 3x for 1.6k. This craziness must be fixed.

Don't spread false information here. BHA is not ticking for 1.6k.

3x BHA usually ticks around 200-600. In some rare cases you might get a 1k tick but that's on very squishy targets with damage boost and armor debuff. On the other hand there are also tanks and guarded WEs or maras where it ticks for pretty much nothing. One hot can counter it.

Post screenshots. That 1.6k is for sure a lie or a one in a million tick.

I have some SSs on my computer but I am currently out of city at the moment. I will post it on Saturday when get back.

[Caduceus]

SWs outdps Slayers these days. It's mental. Maybe they should give SW backlash mechanic.

[Mepiff]

Don't spread false information here. BHA is not ticking for 1.6k.

3x BHA usually ticks around 200-600. In some rare cases you might get a 1k tick but that's on very squishy targets with damage boost and armor debuff. On the other hand there are also tanks and guarded WEs or maras where it ticks for pretty much nothing. One hot can counter it.

Post screenshots. That 1.6k is for sure a lie or a one in a million tick.

WTF is this. I get more then 200-600 as a full Merc fresh 40 SW.
A full BiS SW is going to be getting ~900 non-crit on non-tanks with 3x

How about you show us some proof instead of throwing numbers around.

https://youtu.be/vIQvBcwio14?t=316

Seems to be a healthy mix or spiral fletched critting for 700+ and broadhead cleave in this video, HOWEVER the problem isnt the damage its that it never stops scaling with increasing amount of shadow warriors

[Justina]

WTF is this. I get more then 200-600 as a full Merc fresh 40 SW.
A full BiS SW is going to be getting ~900 non-crit on non-tanks with 3x

How about you show us some proof instead of throwing numbers around.

https://youtu.be/vIQvBcwio14?t=316

Seems to be a healthy mix or spiral fletched critting for 700+ and broadhead cleave in this video, HOWEVER the problem isnt the damage its that it never stops scaling with increasing amount of shadow warriors

So what's the problem? I don't see any damage that can't be done with any other class like magus, engi, bw, sorc, slayer, choppa, mara, WL, ...

It's just a dot and you have to apply it 3 times to get even noticable damage numbers. A dot that does pretty much zero damage on tanks or guarded targets, can be cleansed and gets blocked and evaded a lot. Sure it can be stacked but a lot of things can be stacked. Stack a couple of slayers and everything will die even quicker.

That's the way it is. It's a aoe spam fest. Not only from SWs.

You might not like it that way but we don't like your aoe knock downs, pulls and jumping meatballs either.

[agemennon675]

WTF is this. I get more then 200-600 as a full Merc fresh 40 SW.
A full BiS SW is going to be getting ~900 non-crit on non-tanks with 3x

How about you show us some proof instead of throwing numbers around.

https://youtu.be/vIQvBcwio14?t=316

Seems to be a healthy mix or spiral fletched critting for 700+ and broadhead cleave in this video, HOWEVER the problem isnt the damage its that it never stops scaling with increasing amount of shadow warriors

There is not a single damaging number that does more dmg than say a BW SL WL will do, and all dmg done by any dps goes up as you get more dps, 2 maras will do twice the dmg of 1 mara ? I dont get the pattern here, people annoyed by seeing 3x BHA ? Biggest BHA crit on that video was 360 and it was a crit

[Littleone]

Decorate it as you like but a dot ticking 1.6k is not something normal. Having 4 of them on you simply serves as an oil effect. There is a design mistake on this ability. The dmg of the tick multiplies with each stack. So while 2x BHA crits for 800 and 3x for 1.6k. This craziness must be fixed.

Don't spread false information here. BHA is not ticking for 1.6k.

3x BHA usually ticks around 200-600. In some rare cases you might get a 1k tick but that's on very squishy targets with damage boost and armor debuff. On the other hand there are also tanks and guarded WEs or maras where it ticks for pretty much nothing. One hot can counter it.

Post screenshots. That 1.6k is for sure a lie or a one in a million tick.

Feel free to compare SH dot damage (both yer bleeding and rotten arrrer 65ft crited for 300 XD) to SW one...
Lets not forget SW free casts BHA from 100ft when aoe tactic is not slotted...